Many high‑school students focus laser‑sharp on their personal statement or main application essay but often underestimate the power of their supplemental essays. While not all schools require them, these are the prompts you write for individual colleges which ask things like “Why our school?”, “Tell us about your community involvement”, or “What are your professional goals?” Using a strong brainstorming‑to‑drafting process, tailoring every answer to the specific college, and writing with clarity and reflection will make these essays a major advantage in your application. In this blog you’ll learn why supplemental essays matter, how to prepare ahead of time, how to tackle the main prompt types, how to structure essays of different lengths, and practical tips to make your writing stand out.
>>Want us to help you get accepted? Schedule a free strategy call here.<<
Why Supplemental Essays Are So Important
Whether you are applying to an Ivy League school or a school that's easy to get into, when you apply to college, your transcript, GPA, test scores (if applicable), and list of activities give the admissions committee a broad picture of who you are, but the supplemental essays are where you add color and depth. These essays allow you to:
- Show why you are a good fit for that specific school.
- Explain why you’ll contribute to that campus beyond just what you’ll get out of it.
- Add personal insights, reflections and stories that go beyond your activity list or resume.
- Demonstrate that you responded carefully to the prompt which signals you respect the school and understand their values.
In short: you’re not just showing you can get in, you’re showing you’ll thrive there.
Pre‑Writing: Getting Ready Before the Prompts Arrive
Because many colleges release their supplemental prompts after you submit your main application, you may have only weeks (or even days) to write each one. That’s why advance preparation matters. Make sure that you check the college application timeline.
What You Should Do Ahead:
- Begin brainstorming about your high‑school journey, including meaningful experiences, challenges, activities, identity/community involvement, and why you chose each college.
Why this is good: when you begin with raw material, writing becomes faster and smoother.
- Research the colleges you’re applying to: their mission, campus culture, unique programs, faculty, student life, values.
Why this is good: you’ll be able to reference specific college details instead of generic praise.
- Draft rough responses to common supplemental prompts (e.g., “Why this college?”, “Tell us about a meaningful activity”, “How will you contribute to our community?”).
Why this is good: you’ll save time when the actual prompts arrive and avoid scrambling.
- Organize your materials: keep a list of topics you might reuse (with adaptation), your brainstorming notes, and any previous writing you can draw on.
Why this is good: helps avoid repetition and gives you a head‑start.
The Main Types of Supplemental Essay Prompts & How to Approach Them
1. The “Why Us” / School‑Specific Essay
What it is: A prompt asking why you’ve chosen that particular school.
How to write it:
- Provide specific details about the college (programs, campus culture, extracurriculars) that tie into your academic and personal goals.
- Go beyond the obvious. Don’t just mention “great reputation” or “beautiful campus.”
- Demonstrate what you bring to the college such as clubs you’ll join, communities you’ll serve, or ideas you’ll contribute.
Why this works: Admissions officers want to feel you’ll actively engage on their campus.
2. The Extracurricular Essay
What it is: A prompt asking you to discuss a meaningful activity, talent, or leadership experience.
How to write it:
- Choose an activity that’s meaningful to you and aligned with your values.
- Avoid listing. Instead, focus on the story, lessons, growth, or impact.
- Avoid repeating what’s in your main essay. Offer a new angle or topic.
Why this works: Shows how you grow, reflect, and contribute beyond academics.
3. The Community / Diversity Essay
What it is: A prompt focused on your identity, background, or how you connect with and contribute to communities.
How to write it:
- Identify what makes you unique within your community — cultural, geographic, familial, or otherwise.
- Emphasize a journey of impact and growth.
Why this works: Admissions wants to see diverse voices and thoughtful contributors to their community.
4. The Major / Field of Study Essay
What it is: A prompt asking why you chose your intended field of study.
How to write it:
- Share a personal story or moment that sparked your interest in the field.
- Connect your passion with college-specific offerings like faculty, labs, internships, or research centers.
- Tie in your future goals and how this major is a steppingstone.
Why this works: Shows intellectual curiosity and realistic academic vision.
5. The Quirky / Creative Essay
What it is: A fun or out-of-the-box prompt like “What’s your superpower?”
How to write it:
- Match the tone! Embrace creativity, humor, or surprise.
- Stay grounded in truth. Pick something that reflects your real personality.
Why this works: Showcases your creativity, originality, and voice.
Structuring Your Essay by Length
Short (250 words or fewer)
- Open strong! Get straight to your point.
- Use tight, specific details.
- Conclude with a clear takeaway.
Why this is good: You have limited space. Make every sentence count.
Medium (250‑500 words)
- Begin with a story or vivid detail.
- Stay focused on the prompt with clear transitions.
- End with a memorable insight or summary sentence.
Why this works: You have enough space for nuance, but you still need to stay concise.
Long (500+ words)
- Use an engaging intro that sets the stage.
- Develop your story across 3–5 clear paragraphs.
- Close with reflection and connection to the college or prompt.
Why this works: With space, you can demonstrate complexity, reflection, and voice.
Practical Tips to Make Your Supplemental Essays Stand Out
- Tailor each essay. Use college-specific names, faculty, programs.
- Reflect, don’t just describe. Show how you’ve changed or what you’ve learned.
- Avoid repetition. Each essay should reveal something new.
- Be authentic. Be yourself, not who you think they want.
- Use active language. Avoid passive voice or vague generalizations.
- Start early. Supplemental essays sneak up fast. Get ahead.
- Proofread carefully. Spelling a college’s name wrong is a deal-breaker.
- Get feedback. Ask a counselor or trusted adult to read your drafts. Admissions experts can help you succeed.
Final Checklist Before You Submit
- Did you answer the prompt directly?
- Is your writing specific to that college?
- Have you included reflection or personal growth?
- Does your voice sound natural and confident?
- Are you within the word limit?
- Have you avoided overlap with your main essay?
- Did you show what you’ll contribute and not just what you want?
- Did you revise and proofread?
Closing Thoughts
Supplemental essays are not just “extra”; they’re your chance to make a stronger impression, one college at a time. Done well, these essays show that you’ve researched each school, reflected deeply on your experiences, and have a vision for your college years. Prepare early, revise with care, and approach each essay like a conversation rather than a formality. That’s how you stand out.
FAQs
1. What’s the difference between personal statements and supplemental essays?
The personal statement is your main Common App essay; supplemental essays are school-specific and tailored to individual prompts.
2. How many supplemental essays do I have to write?
It varies. Some colleges ask for 1–2, others might ask for 5+ responses, often of different lengths.
3. Can I reuse supplemental essays for different schools?
Sometimes, but only if the prompts are very similar. Always customize each version for the specific college.
4. What’s a good length for a supplemental essay?
That depends on the prompt. Common ranges are 150, 250, 350, or 500 words. Always follow the limit provided.
5. When should I start working on supplemental essays?
Start brainstorming and drafting in the summer or early fall. It’s a good idea to start brainstorming before the prompts are released, especially if the school releases the prompts without much time to complete them.
6. Should I be formal or casual in tone?
Strike a balance and be authentic, respectful, and reflective. Use your real voice.
7. What mistakes should I avoid in supplemental essays?
Don’t be generic, repeat yourself, ignore the word count, or write without researching the school.
8. What if I don’t know my major yet?
Write about your current interests and curiosity. Colleges value open-mindedness and a desire to explore.
To your success,
Your friends at BeMo
Like our blog? Write for us! >>
Have a question? Ask our admissions experts below and we'll answer your questions!
Comments